Farmers Carry vs. Rucking: Which Loaded Carry is Right for You?

Loaded carries are a cornerstone of functional fitness, building real-world strength and endurance. Among the most effective loaded carries are the farmer’s carry and rucking. While both involve carrying weight, they offer distinct benefits and target different aspects of fitness. This comprehensive guide will delve into the nuances of farmer’s carry vs. rucking, helping you determine which exercise best aligns with your fitness goals.

What is the Farmer’s Carry?

The farmer’s carry, also known as the farmer’s walk, is a strength exercise where you hold heavy weights in each hand and walk for a specified distance or time. Imagine a farmer carrying buckets of milk – that’s the essence of this exercise. Typically, you’ll use dumbbells, kettlebells, or farmer’s carry handles, holding them with a strong grip as you maintain good posture and walk.

Benefits of Farmer’s Carry

• Grip Strength: Farmer’s carries are arguably the best exercise for developing crushing grip strength. Holding heavy weights for extended periods significantly strengthens your hands and forearms.
• Full-Body Strength: While seemingly simple, farmer’s carries engage muscles throughout your body. Your traps, shoulders, core, back, and legs work synergistically to stabilize and move the load.
• Core Stability: Maintaining an upright posture with heavy weights demands significant core engagement, strengthening your obliques, erector spinae, and transverse abdominis.
• Shoulder Health: Farmer’s carries can improve shoulder stability and resilience when performed with proper form, strengthening the muscles surrounding the shoulder joint.
• Functional Strength: This exercise directly translates to real-world activities, making everyday tasks like carrying groceries or luggage easier.
• Metabolic Conditioning: Performing farmer’s carries with heavier weights can elevate your heart rate and improve metabolic conditioning, especially when incorporated into circuits or complexes.

Muscles Worked in Farmer’s Carry

• Grip and Forearms: Extensor and flexor muscles of the forearms.
• Trapezius: Upper and middle traps for shoulder stabilization and elevation.
• Deltoids: Anterior, medial, and posterior deltoids for shoulder stability and carrying the weight.
• Core: Rectus abdominis, obliques, transverse abdominis, and erector spinae for spinal stability and posture.
• Legs: Quadriceps, hamstrings, and calves for locomotion and support.

How to Perform Farmer’s Carry

1. Select Your Weights: Choose weights that are challenging but allow you to maintain good form. Start lighter and gradually increase the load as your strength improves.
2. Grip the Weights: Stand with your feet shoulder-width apart and grip the handles of your dumbbells, kettlebells, or farmer’s carry handles firmly.
3. Stand Tall: Engage your core, straighten your back, and stand tall with your shoulders pulled back and down. Avoid rounding your shoulders.
4. Walk with Purpose: Walk with controlled steps, maintaining good posture and a tight grip. Avoid letting the weights swing excessively.
5. Distance or Time: Walk for a predetermined distance or time. Rest and repeat for desired sets.

What is Rucking?

Rucking is essentially walking with a weighted backpack. Originating from military training, rucking builds endurance, strengthens your legs and back, and improves cardiovascular fitness. It’s a simple yet highly effective way to train, requiring minimal equipment and adaptable to various fitness levels. You can ruck on trails, sidewalks, or even a treadmill.

Benefits of Rucking

• Cardiovascular Fitness: Rucking elevates your heart rate and improves your aerobic capacity, enhancing your overall cardiovascular health. Research suggests that rucking can be an effective form of low-impact cardio.
• Muscular Endurance: Carrying a weighted pack for extended periods builds muscular endurance in your legs, back, and core.
• Leg Strength: Rucking strengthens your quadriceps, hamstrings, glutes, and calves, preparing you for activities like hiking and climbing.
• Posture Improvement: Rucking encourages good posture by engaging your core and back muscles to support the weight, potentially mitigating slouching.
• Low Impact: Compared to running, rucking is a lower-impact activity, reducing stress on your joints while still providing significant cardiovascular and muscular benefits.
• Accessibility: Rucking requires minimal equipment – a backpack and weights – making it accessible to almost anyone, anywhere.
• Mental Toughness: Rucking can be mentally challenging, especially over longer distances or with heavier loads, fostering mental resilience and discipline.

Muscles Worked in Rucking

• Legs: Quadriceps, hamstrings, glutes, and calves are the primary movers during rucking.
• Core: Erector spinae, obliques, and transverse abdominis work to stabilize your spine and maintain posture under load.
• Back: Latissimus dorsi and rhomboids assist in maintaining posture and supporting the weight in the backpack.
• Shoulders: While less directly involved than in farmer’s carry, shoulders still engage to stabilize the backpack.

How to Perform Rucking

1. Choose a Backpack: Select a sturdy backpack that fits comfortably and has padded straps.
2. Add Weight: Start with 10-20% of your body weight and gradually increase as you get stronger. Use weight plates, sandbags, or even water bottles. Distribute the weight evenly in the backpack and keep it high and close to your back.
3. Proper Pack Fit: Adjust the straps so the pack sits high on your back and the weight is supported by your hips, not just your shoulders.
4. Maintain Good Posture: Stand tall, engage your core, and maintain a natural stride. Avoid leaning forward excessively.
5. Start Walking: Begin walking at a brisk pace. Focus on maintaining good form throughout your ruck.
6. Distance or Time: Ruck for a set distance or time, gradually increasing duration and/or weight as you progress.

Farmers Carry vs. Rucking: Key Differences

While both farmer’s carry and rucking are loaded carries, their primary focus and benefits differ significantly.

Benefits of Farmer’s Carry: In Detail

Let’s explore the benefits of farmer’s carry in more depth:

• Unmatched Grip Strength Development: Farmer’s carries are unparalleled for building grip strength. The sustained isometric contraction required to hold heavy weights challenges your grip endurance and maximal grip strength. This translates to improved performance in other exercises like deadlifts, pull-ups, and rows, as well as everyday tasks.
• Comprehensive Upper Body Strength: Beyond grip, farmer’s carries heavily engage your traps, shoulders, and core. They build robust upper back and shoulder musculature, contributing to better posture and injury prevention.
• Rock-Solid Core Stability: Maintaining stability while carrying heavy weights demands intense core activation. Farmer’s carries train your core in a functional, real-world manner, improving your ability to stabilize your spine under load and enhancing overall core strength.
• Functional, Real-World Strength: Farmer’s carries mimic real-life lifting and carrying tasks. This functional strength translates directly to activities like carrying groceries, moving furniture, and performing manual labor, making everyday life easier and more resilient.

Benefits of Rucking: In Detail

Let’s delve deeper into the advantages of rucking:

• Effective Cardiovascular Conditioning: Rucking provides a sustainable and enjoyable way to improve cardiovascular fitness. It’s a low-impact alternative to running that still elevates your heart rate and burns calories, making it ideal for those seeking to improve endurance without excessive joint stress. Studies on load carriage support its cardiovascular benefits.
• Lower Body Power and Endurance: Rucking builds significant leg strength and endurance. The added weight challenges your leg muscles over extended periods, strengthening your quads, hamstrings, glutes, and calves. This translates to improved hiking ability, hill climbing power, and overall lower body resilience.
• Enhanced Posture and Back Health: When performed correctly, rucking encourages good posture and strengthens the muscles responsible for spinal stability. This can help counteract the effects of prolonged sitting and improve overall back health.
• Mental Fortitude and Resilience: Rucking can be mentally challenging, especially on longer rucks or with heavier loads. Overcoming these challenges builds mental toughness, discipline, and resilience, qualities that extend beyond physical fitness into other areas of life.

Choosing Between Farmer’s Carry and Rucking (or Combining Them)

The best choice between farmer’s carry and rucking depends on your individual fitness goals:

• Choose Farmer’s Carry If:
  • Your primary goal is to improve grip strength.
  • You want to build upper body and core strength.
  • You are focused on functional strength for daily tasks and lifting.
  • You prefer shorter, more intense strength training sessions.
• Choose Rucking If:
  • Your primary goal is to improve cardiovascular endurance.
  • You want to build leg strength and endurance.
  • You are interested in low-impact cardio and outdoor activities.
  • You want to improve mental toughness and resilience.
• Combine Farmer’s Carry and Rucking If:
  • You want a well-rounded fitness program that addresses both strength and endurance.
  • You enjoy variety in your training.
  • You want to maximize functional fitness and overall physical preparedness.

Combining both exercises can be a highly effective strategy. For example, you could incorporate farmer’s carries into your strength training days and dedicate separate days to rucking for endurance. You could also include short bursts of farmer’s carries within a rucking workout to add strength intervals.

Key Takeaways

• Farmer’s carry excels at building grip strength, upper body strength, and core stability, making it ideal for functional strength and power development.
• Rucking is superior for improving cardiovascular endurance, leg strength, and mental toughness, offering a low-impact way to build full-body endurance.
• Both are excellent forms of loaded carries and contribute to overall fitness.
• Your fitness goals should dictate which exercise (or combination) is best for you.
• Consider incorporating both farmer’s carry and rucking into a well-rounded training program for comprehensive fitness benefits.

FAQ

Q: Can I do farmer’s carries and rucking on the same day?

A: Yes, you can. You could perform farmer’s carries as part of your strength training routine and then go for a ruck afterward as cardio, or vice versa. Listen to your body and adjust volume and intensity accordingly.

Q: Which is better for weight loss, farmer’s carry or rucking?

A: Both can contribute to weight loss as they burn calories. Rucking, being a more sustained aerobic activity, might burn more calories over longer durations. However, farmer’s carries can also be metabolically demanding when performed with heavier weights and shorter rest periods. A combination of both, along with a healthy diet, is likely most effective for weight loss.

Q: What kind of weight should I use for farmer’s carries and rucking?

A: For farmer’s carries, start with a weight that allows you to walk with good form for 50-100 meters. For rucking, begin with 10-20% of your body weight and gradually increase as you get stronger. Focus on maintaining good posture and listening to your body.

Q: Are farmer’s carries or rucking better for beginners?

A: Rucking is often considered more beginner-friendly due to its lower technical demand and ease of progression. Farmer’s carries require more grip strength and may be more challenging initially for complete beginners. However, both can be modified to suit different fitness levels.

Q: Do I need special equipment for farmer’s carries or rucking?

A: For farmer’s carries, dumbbells or kettlebells are ideal, but you can use various weighted objects. For rucking, you need a backpack and weights. While specialized rucking backpacks and weight plates are available, you can start with a regular backpack and household items for weight.

Conclusion

Farmer’s carry and rucking are both incredibly valuable loaded carry exercises, each offering unique benefits. Understanding their differences allows you to strategically incorporate them into your training for targeted results. Whether you prioritize grip strength and functional power or cardiovascular endurance and leg strength, both farmer’s carry and rucking deserve a place in a well-rounded fitness regimen. Experiment with both to discover which best suits your goals and enjoy the journey of building a stronger, more resilient you.

Disclaimer: Consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new exercise program, especially if you have any underlying health conditions.

References

• Effects of Load Carriage on Physiological and Perceptual Responses During Walking. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 2019.
• The Physiological Response to Load Carriage in Military Personnel: A Systematic Review. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2019.
• General research on grip strength training benefits can be found on platforms like Google Scholar by searching for terms like “grip strength training benefits” or “loaded carries benefits”.

Written By:

Daniel Harrington

Chief Ruck Writer

Daniel Harrington, Chief Ruck Writer at RuckQuest, brings over a decade of experience in military training and fitness coaching, specializing in rucking techniques and strategies. With a passion for outdoor activities and a commitment to helping others succeed, he provides expert insights, comprehensive guides, and valuable gear reviews for ruckers of all levels.

More About the Author